Free Tools

Rent vs. buy calculator.

Compare illustrative ownership and rental outcomes over time.

Rent vs buy calculator

Modeled owner minus renter wealth after 7 yrs
-$21,283
Total rent paid
$220,679
Owner cash outlay incl. down payment
$445,422
Sale proceeds after costs and payoff
$258,303
Owning monthly cost
$3,862
Remaining mortgage
$399,465
Renter investment balance
$279,587
Owner investment balance
$0

Illustrative assumptions, not a forecast. Both households invest monthly housing-cost differences; renters also invest the avoided down payment and buying costs. Includes entered expenses, mortgage payoff and sale costs. No tax benefits or inflation adjustment; expenses except rent stay constant. Test lower appreciation and different holding periods.

Rent vs. buy — the real math

Renting vs. buying is one of the most personal financial decisions — it depends on how long you plan to stay, your financial situation, and the local market dynamics.

Factors favoring buying

  • Appreciation can build equity, but prices can also stagnate or fall; test more than one assumption.
  • Principal paydown builds equity every month
  • Fixed-rate principal and interest stay stable; taxes, insurance, HOA dues and rent may change.
  • Tax deductions on mortgage interest and property taxes (consult a tax advisor)
  • Freedom to renovate and customize

Factors favoring renting

  • No maintenance or repair costs
  • Flexibility to move without selling
  • Down payment and closing costs remain invested elsewhere
  • Makes sense in very high-cost markets where P&I far exceeds rent equivalent

There is no universal four-year break-even. Purchase and sale costs, principal payoff, appreciation, local expenses and the return on cash invested elsewhere all affect the comparison. Both households are assumed to invest any monthly housing-cost advantage.

This calculator provides an estimate. Tax implications, actual appreciation, and maintenance costs vary significantly. Consult a financial advisor for personalized guidance.

Related: Mortgage payment calculator · Get pre-approved · First-time homebuyer Colorado

Get a personalized quote.

Real numbers from a licensed Colorado & Florida mortgage broker.

From an estimate to a lending decision

Illustrative calculator results are not rate quotes, appraisals or approvals. Replace assumptions with the actual property’s expenses and lender terms. The result can change materially with insurance, taxes, HOA dues, mortgage insurance, loan term and financed fees.

  • Verify taxes and insurance separately from principal and interest.
  • Include required mortgage insurance and transaction costs where the calculation calls for them.
  • Try a less favorable rate, rent or appreciation assumption before relying on the result.
Get started

See your loan options in minutes.

Tell us a little about you and we'll reach out personally — usually within one business day.

Or call (970) 708-9624

Terms · Privacy Policy