Compare the whole borrowing cost
A HELOC can preserve your existing first mortgage, while a home equity loan provides a separate lump sum and a cash-out refinance replaces that mortgage. None is automatically cheaper. Compare the combined payment, fees, variable-rate risk, repayment term and remaining balances over the time you expect to borrow.
- Compare the same cash amount and payoff timeline across all three options.
- Ask about a HELOC’s margin, introductory period, rate caps, minimum draws and repayment-period payment.
- Include closing costs and the effect of refinancing your entire existing balance.
- Remember the home secures the debt; payment difficulties can put ownership at risk.

