Investing in Monroe County
Monroe County covers 4 rental markets we actively finance in Florida — Big Pine Key, Islamorada, Key West, Marathon. Across those markets the median investment basis averages $812,500, a long-term lease averages $4,525/month, and the average all-in PITIA on a DSCR loan at the minimum down payment is $6,237. That produces a county-wide average DSCR ratio near 0.74x.
Basis varies more inside Monroe County than the average suggests. Big Pine Key is the lowest entry point at roughly $625,000, while Big Pine Key currently models the strongest coverage ratio in the county at 0.88x. When two towns in the same county ratio differently, it is almost always the rent-to-price relationship rather than the rate — the same loan pricing applies county-wide, so the deal is won on which submarket you buy in.

